Skip to main content

Sustainable Stocking Stuffers

Stocking Stuffer Season has arrived! We’ve gathered our favorite tried-and-true goodies along with a few new finds we can’t get enough of — including treats and toys for your favorite fur babies.

Skip to pagination
Reusable and compostable cleaning cloth depicting vivid red cardinals perched amidst a white and grey wintry scene
Cheerful white snowmen with black top hats and orange carrot noses smile against a pale gray winter back on this reusable dishcloth

Reusable Swedish Dishcloth

$6.95

Handmade Felt Hanging Decorations

From$9.95
A brownish soap bar with an embossed gingerbread man and the French phrase "Bonnes Fêtes" below.

French Soap Bars

$8.95
Close-up of hands wearing handmade alpaca fingerless mittens with a striped knit pattern in purple, blue, green, and red.

Alpaca Fingerless Mittens | Handmade, Fair Trade, 100% Alpaca Fiber

$39.95
New
Lip tint container with 'Lovett Sundries' branding on a white background
Close-up of a woman putting  lip tint balm in her lips.

All Natural 3-in-1 Tint Tin - Lip, Blush & Eye

$10.95
Colorful packaging of Seattle Chocolate's Mexican Hot Cocoa with illustrations on a white background
Chocolate bar packaging with cartoon characters and pumpkin spice chai text on a white background

Fair-Trade Maeve Chocolate Bars

$8.95
A single soap saver bag, made from a woven, light-colored natural material, lies on a white background. It has a drawstring with a bamboo bead and a "Free the OCEAN" tag
A light-colored bar of soap sits halfway inside a beige, woven soap saver bag with a drawstring, resting on a white marble surface

FTO Exfoliating Soap Saver Bag

$3.95
A glass jar containing a stack of eight white, circular shower steamers. A label on the front of the jar reads "EUCALYPTUS STEAM. Cleansing Vapors for the shower.
Two sizes of 'No Tox Life' Eucalyptus Steams. One jar is tall and full of round shower steamers. The other jar is short and also contains the round shower steamers.

Eucalyptus Shower Steamer Discs

From$19.95
A silver tin of garden sprinkles with a white label on the lid. The label features a watercolor illustration of several sprigs of purple lavender flowers, with the text 'lavender, potting shed creations' around the edge.
A silver tin of garden sprinkles with a white label on the lid. The label features a watercolor illustration of a sprig of light blue forget-me-not flowers, with the text 'forget-me-not, potting shed creations' around the edge.

Garden Sprinkles

$4.95
A round, silver tin is shown hanging from a pine branch by a red and green plaid ribbon. The tin's lid features an illustration of a black dog rolling in grass and the words "dog grass" are printed on it. Other text on the tin includes a business name and location.

Sprinkle Holiday Ornaments

From$5.95
Pair of rustic driftwood Christmas house ornaments painted in green and burgundy with natural twine for hanging. Handmade from recycled materials, supporting fair-trade artisans in the Philippines.
Close view of a hand holding a handcrafted driftwood Christmas house ornament with festive green paint. Eco-friendly and fair-trade, made from recycled driftwood.

Handmade Recycled Driftwood Christmas House Ornament Decoration

$14.95
Caramel-toned bracelet made from recycled ocean plastic and finished with an adjustable cotton cord. Eco-conscious and handmade in Bali.
Stack of recycled ocean plastic bead bracelets in various colors, worn on a wrist. Adjustable cotton cords and stainless steel charms, handmade in Bali and water-safe.

Recycled Ocean Plastic Bracelet

$14.00
Recycled, handmade driftwood star decoration with clay nativity figures, copper star center, and festive greenery on a white mantel.
Recycled driftwood and clay nativity ornament with Mary, Joseph, and baby Jesus, handmade and eco-friendly holiday decoration.

Handmade Recycled Driftwood Christmas Nativity Decoration

$19.95
A pair of green socks with a pattern of red and white porcupines is shown against a white background. The brand name is visible on the bottom of the socks.
A person is shown seated on a brown paisley couch wearing gray pants and green socks with a pattern of red and white dogs. A small, shaggy, light-colored dog is lying next to the person looking at the camera.

Cozy Socks for a Cause

$16.95
Bundle of black FTO biodegradable hair ties on a white background.
Three black FTO plastic-free hair ties resting in a blue seashell-shaped dish, next to a cardboard card holding hair ties.

FTO Plastic-Free Hair Ties Pack

$12.95
Close-up of an eco-friendly FTO bamboo hairbrush showing bamboo bristles and a smooth beeswax-coated handle on a white background.
FTO bamboo hairbrush inside blue cardboard packaging, placed on a tiled surface next to a green plant.

FTO Bamboo Hairbrush

$14.95
An eye pillow with a vibrant floral pattern features large pink and red flowers with bright green leaves and small berries.
A rectangular eye pillow by Dana Herbert has a vibrant floral pattern with pink and white flowers on a mustard yellow background.

Relaxation Eye Pillow

$23.95
Chagrin Valley Soap & Salve Company lemon lime shaving soap bar on a white background
Three bars of soap with a lime and lemon on a wooden surface

Organic All-Natural Shaving Soap

$12.95
Jar of Chagrin Valley Soap & Salve Company Natural Scent After Shave & Beard Balm on a white background
Jar of Woodland Breeze after shave & beard balm from Chagrin Valley Soap & Salve Company on a white background

Organic All-Natural AfterShave & Beard Balm

$24.95
New

Poppy & Pout Lip Mask

$21.95
New
Jar of Lovett Sundries shower steamers mix pack with individual tablets on a white background
Glass jar of Lovett Sundries shower steamers with colorful bath bombs on a white background

Shower Steamers Aroma Therapy

$27.95
New
Peppermint lip balm in a tin with 'Lovett Sundries' branding on a white background
Lip balm being held between two fingers with a white background

All Natural Lip Balm Tin

$8.95
Elegant gold heart necklace hanging from a slender chain, symbolizing care for the sea and responsible fashion.
Close-up of a gold chain necklace featuring a detailed tiger pendant, symbolizing strength and wildlife conservation.

14K Gold-Plated Necklace

$40.00
Close-up of a Sweet Mint Poppy & Pout lip balm in a compostable cardboard tube on a neutral background.

Poppy & Pout Lip Balms

$10.95
Set of 12 round reusable makeup remover pads neatly stacked on a white background, showcasing their soft, natural fabric texture.
Three reusable makeup remover pads placed on a clear brown fabric cloth with a small branch of white flowers on a brown background.

FTO Makeup Remover Rounds & Wash Bag

$16.95
Open glass jar of rosewater face cream on a white surface, showing white cream inside and labeled metal lid beside it."
Rosewater face cream jar with rose petals on the sides.

Rosewater Face Cream

$34.00

Recycled Magazine Ornament | Handmade, Fair Trade

$9.95
Sixteen colorful, rock-shaped Crayon Rocks are fanned out above a natural drawstring bag, showcasing the unique form designed to aid grip.
Five blue stars above a customer testimonial: "My granddaughters all love the feel of them and the beautiful drawings they can make with these crayons." Below, a paper with crayon drawings, colorful Crayon Rocks, and their bag are displayed.

Crayon Rocks

$12.95
Mini Block Print Stamps Set
Mini Block Print Stamps Set

Mini Block Print Stamps Set

$17.95

Organic Grow Tins

$11.95
Graphic image of a Free the Ocean gift card featuring ocean-themed artwork and eco-friendly messaging, symbolizing a sustainable gift choice.
Close-up of a hand wearing a blue fingerless mitten holding a Free the Ocean gift card, highlighting the perfect eco-conscious present for friends and family.

Gift Card

From$10.00
New
Poppy & Pout lip care pomegranate Peach duo including a jar and a stick with packaging on a white background.
Hand holding a decorative Lip Care duo Island Coconut,  with a beach in the background.

Poppy & Pout Lip Care Duo Gift Set

$26.95
A brown bag of dog treats is shown on a white background. The bag is labeled "Delightfully Delicious Oven Baked All Natural Dog Treats" and "Made with Peanut Butter". The bag has a bone-shaped cutout revealing the treats inside, and it also notes that the treats are "Baked in USA" and contain "no corn, wheat or soy".
A stack of bone-shaped dog treats is shown against a white background, with a single biscuit standing on its end to the side. The treats are a light brown color with an oatmeal-like texture.

All Natural Dog Treats

$10.95
A sustainable bamboo Dog Brush. One side is a bristle brush, and the other is a pin brush for detangling and smoothing hair.
A hand gently brushes a black and white dog's fur with a two-sided bamboo pet brush, showing a moment of care and grooming for a beloved companion.

Bamboo Dog Brush

$14.95
Perry the Panda wool cat toy featuring a hand-felted black and white panda face with stitched eyes and ears, shown on a clean white background.Plush Toys For Cats
Berta the Honeybee wool cat toy, hand-felted in black, yellow, and white wool with stitched wings, on a white background.

Wool Cat Toys

$5.95
A wool donut toy with pink “frosting” and sprinkles, made with natural wool and organic catnip.
A bright rainbow-shaped wool cat toy, handmade with natural wool and infused with catnip for hours of fun.

Wool Cat Toys Infused with Catnip

From$9.95
1 of 3

Your Cart

Your cart is currently empty.
Click here to continue shopping.